Stem cell research refers to scientific research on elements within the human body known as stem cells for the purposes of achieving medical. The stem cell controversy is the consideration of the ethics of research involving the. This information indicates that through stem cells, researchers are close to having a valuable weapon against the number one killer in the world, heart disease. Cloning will destroy the unity of marriage and parenthood. Sample essay against stem cell research and cloning ultius. Stem cell debates have motivated and reinvigorated the antiabortion movement, whose members. This ban was in part revoked by his successor barack obama, who stated. However, evidence has recently emerged that adult cells may be more. Examining the ethics of embryonic stem cell research. Good arguments can be made both for and against paying donors of research.
Adult stem cells would not be that interesting because they do not have the same properties as stem cells from a fetus. Adult stem cells obviously have a universal program for division that is common to all the kinds of tissue stem cells, and makes them mutually interchangeable. One of the other important arguments against stem cells research is that there has been virtually no real successful cure or even a potential for cure found to support destroying the beginning of life, theres no evidence that a destroyed human embryo will help someone. List of books and articles about stem cell research online. European court bans stem cell patents eurostemcell. In 20002001, governments worldwide were beginning to draft proposals and guidelines to control stem cell research and the handling of embryonic tissues and reach universal policies. Aug 14, 2019 the debates over the ethics of stem cell research began almost immediately in 1999, despite reports that stem cells cannot grow into complete organisms. The intention of stem cell research is to produce treatments for human diseases.
In contrast, adult stem cell might not divide fast enough to offer immediate treatment. There may a lot of it if you dont start at it until college but each element is easy to understand. Jul 17, 2000 if we want to pursue medical research using embryonic stem cells, we have to face the problems that the extraction of these cells from a human embryo brings with it. In the researchs defense, stem cells can be used to cure, or at least treat, diseases including leukemia and parkinsons disease. List of books and articles about stem cell research. New excitement, persistent questions, 290 science 16724 1 december 2000 at 1674. On the scientists continue stem cell research while courts debate ban spencer. Stem cells, through a religious lens harvard gazette.
Apr 01, 2005 when university of wisconsin researcher james thomson isolated human embryonic stem cells for the first time in 1998, it touched off a new era in stem cell science and a new wave of political. Jun 27, 2014 this video is taught at the high school level. Mar 15, 2001 in part, this is the characteristic reaction of luddites, who regard all technological innovation as threatening and look back nostalgically to a fictitious, golden, preindustrial past. Arguments in support of embryonic stem cell funding congress had previously prohibited federal funds from being used for destruction of embryos, but president obama only authorized the use of such funds for stem cell research on the ph. Panama stem cell therapy clinic the university of kansas took a lead role in adult stem cell research by establishing the midwest stem cell therapy center is the catholic church opposed to all stem cell research. The final arguments against stem cell research deal with the actual cost of such treatments is simply too high to be implemented on a large scale. The battle to stop human cloning will be a most important opportunity to turn the tide against the culture of death.
Banning embryonic stem cell patents not only imperils. A stem cell is defined as a cell that can divide continuously and develop into several other types of tissues and cells. The case against federal funding of human embryonic stem cell research david a. Those in opposition to this likely will claim that researching stem cell research will kill a fertilized egg, but my key point refutes this since whatever embryos are not utilized will be terminated. Researchers have developed other ways to extract stem cells without having to harm the embryo. This decision is based on the argument that even established embryonic stem cell lines were originally derived from fertilized eggs.
An investigation of the economic and ethical arguments made against research with human embryonic stem cells article pdf available in embo reports 23. In 2001 bush successively passed a bill banning federal funding for embryonic stem cell research. This video discusses what stem cells are and why their research is a divisive issue in todays society. A stem cell can be used to generate large numbers of similar cells from a limited source. Scientists have long promised spectacular results from embryonic stem cell research, and this has not yet occurred. In the context of stem cell research, this may be summed up by kants injunction that humanity is to be treated as an end in itself. Thus, bone marrow stem cells have been induced to become brain cells, but also liver cells.
The good news about stem is that the material is straightforward, organized and coherent. This sample expository essay explores the argument against stem cell research. However, all the arguments of opponents of the stem cells research are irrelevant to the huge potential and benefits the research can bring to the mankind. In part, this is the characteristic reaction of luddites, who regard all technological innovation as threatening and look back nostalgically to a fictitious, golden, preindustrial past. Opponents claim that since the cells come from an embryo, these cells are alive and extracting these cells means the death of a living organismwhich is immoral wes99.
Bush, who had campaigned against financing embryonic stem cell research, announced in aug. The debates over the ethics of stem cell research began almost immediately in 1999, despite reports that stem cells cannot grow into complete organisms. Discover librarianselected research resources on stem cell research from the questia online library, including fulltext online books, academic journals. Against the restrictive viewpoint that research on hes cells may only take place if there is proof that adult stem cells are not optimally useful, there is the more permissive viewpoint that hes cell research may, and indeed should, take place so long it is unclear whether adult stem cells are complete or even partial alternatives. Arguments for and against embryonic stem cell research. However, human stem cell hsc research also raises sharp ethical and political controversies. Pdf stem cell researchwhy is it regarded as a threat. Cards can then be used to structure arguments for against the use of stem cells. There is, however, a further argument against this particular threat. Arguments for stem cell research pros stem cell medical.
Adult stem cells another type of stem cell exists, called the adult stem cell. Opponents argue that the research is unethical, because deriving the stem cells destroys the blastocyst, an unimplanted human embryo at the sixth to. Beyond the substantial legal and ethical dilemmas inherent in such research, the scientific evidence shows that adult stem cells have. The arguments against federal funding are generally those that assert that the destruction of the embryo for the removal of the stem cells embodies the principle that nonconsenting human beings must not be subjected to medical experimentation, and that in obtaining stem cells from embryos, it is necessary to kill a growing human being. Critics against stem cell research argued that the ethical issues of scientific work on aborted fetuses did not justify the possible benefits.
What are the best arguments against studying the stem fields. The following list was obtained from the rsc republican study committee, rep. Groups against the stem cell research enhancement act. Research news opinion research analysis careers books and culture podcasts videos. Arguments for and against embryonic stem cell research embryonic stem cell research has sparked a heated debate on ethics.
Eu ban on stem cell patents is a threat both to science and the rule. A bulwark against trumps stem cell ban californias institute for regenerative medicine, a kind of mininih, does crucial basic research without federal funding by zachary brown on july 2, 2019. Mar 22, 2007 representatives of three of the worlds major religions tangled over the beginnings of human life, the disposal of surplus embryos from in vitro fertilization clinics, and the conduct of embryonic stem cell research wednesday march 14 at harvard divinity school. In this case, the embryo is taken and the potential human being is destroyed. Ethicists make the case for bone marrow transplantation markets. Stem cells are found in limited quantities in every human body and can be extracted from adult tissue with great effort but without harm. Key to the argument of bush and others who oppose embryonic stem cell research is the idea that an embryo a fertilized egg in its early stages of development, before it has reached a. The challenges of making docs about women and why its so crucial to. Nov 09, 2014 pupils read peoples opinions on embryonic stem cell research. Proponents argue that embryonic stem cell research holds great promise for understanding and curing diabetes, parkinsons disease, spinal cord injury, and other debilitating conditions.
Embryonic stem cell ethics card sort teaching resources. Embryonic stem cells divide more rapidly than adult stem cells, potentially making it easier to generate large numbers of cells for therapeutic means. Stem cells for research can be successfully obtained from other sources like umbilical cord stem cells, amniotic fluid. In a case brought by greenpeace against the german neuroscientist. Aborted fetuses are not the only source of stem cells. The problem is with embryonic stem cells, which are derived from fertilized eggs. Another concern with embryonic stem cell treatments is a tendency of stem cells from embryos to create tumors. Relative ease of procurementsome adult stem cells are easy to harvest skin, muscle, marrow, fat, while others may be more difficult to obtain brain stem cells. Much of the world became familiar with cloning in 1997, when scientists. Arguments against stem cell research treatment stem cell. The main arguments against scnt or embryonic stem cell. On the other hand, some contend that it is unfair to ban payments to donors of.
Jul 07, 2008 two prolife groups staged a sitin outside the california office of the department of health and human services on thursday, challenging president bush to enforce an amendment banning embryonic stem cell research. Most scientists believe that embryonic stem cells hold the key to curing hundreds of diseases. Weiss, clone study casts doubt on stem cells, the washington post, july 6, 2001, a1 and a9. Feb 10, 2008 not immunogenicrecipients who receive the products of their own stem cells will. There are, however, also serious arguments that have been made against stem cell research. What are some of the arguments put forth against and in support of embryonic stem cell research. Arguments for embryonic stem cell research stem cells.
Jeb hensnarling, rtx, chairman, 2 cannon house office. The consensus among researchers has been that adult stem cells are limited in usefulness because they can be used to produce only a few of the 220 types of cells found in the human body. Conspicuously, such criticism has even come from researchers themselves. There are stem cells in the both placenta and blood contained in the placenta. Mar 09, 2007 there arent any religious arguments against stem cell research in whole. Embryonic stem cells have greater plasticity, allowing them to treat a wider range of diseases. The case against federal funding of human embryonic stem cell. Human embryonic stemcell research is not only ethical, it is an essential field to pursue to make key advances in biomedical research to treat diseases effectively where there are currently no curesincluding, but not limited to, paralysis from spinal cord injury, diabetes, parkinsons disease and cancer.
The debate about the ethics of stem cell research has reached an international level, and has spurred on widespread concern about biomedical research in general. This was discovered by alexei terskikh at stanford university school of medicine in california. Stem cell research debate arguments stem cell medical. Sort the cards into for and against embryonic stem cell research. Human embryo research is illegal, immoral, and unnecessary. Thus, there are many kinds of adult stem cells, each capable of repairing only the tissue they are destined to become. Prolife groups protest embryonic stem cell research cnsnews. Work with human embryonic stem cells is contrary to ethics. Some scientists challenged the assumption that these 60 stem cell lines would be. These cells have the same dna and the same set of genes as embryonic stem cells.
Stem cell research pros and cons have gained a lot of attention lately due to president obama lifting a ban on stem cell research. Stem cell research article, embryonic cells information, cell. Stem cells that are partway down one of these branches are called adult stem cells, because they are destined to become specific types of tissue in the adult and are thought to have lost the full potential of embryonic stem cells. Arguments against embryonic stem cell research stem cells. Umbilical and placental stem cells are likely to be readily. The research would give great insights about the basics of the body. Sep 12, 2016 ethicists make the case for bone marrow transplantation markets. Here are some talking points to help you discuss the topic of cloning with elected officials and fellow citizens.
Religious arguments against stem cell research andor. Thus, it seems that the moral objections to stem cell research, on the basis of the moral status of the 1 while popular belief may have it that stem cells are extracted from embryos, stem cells are actually made by scientists, grown out of cells taken from embryos. Stem cells have been shown to reverse paralysis in quadriplegics and furthermore have been used to recreate organic tissue like hearts and the like. The use of federal funds for human embryonic stem cell research is unwarranted. Also the primary source of stem cells is from blastocysts. May 25, 2019 stem cells are found in limited quantities in every human body and can be extracted from adult tissue with great effort but without harm. Panelists at the event, representing christianity, judaism, and islam, each briefly presented their faiths teachings about the. It is difficult not to regard this as a worthy end, and more difficult to see that there could be any moral objection to curing the sick, as demanded by the hippocratic oath.
1388 484 201 1396 976 563 415 1181 914 72 370 74 406 780 590 747 262 897 332 200 1344 842 142 1071 614 1376 987 719 1253 45 1067 777 265 930 1200